Skip to content
MC

2026Article · PLOS Computational Biology

Can multiple matings change how well biological control works?

Polyandry: A threat or an opportunity for the sterile insect technique?

In brief

In Drosophila suzukii, a female can mate with several males and keep their sperm. Using a mathematical model and simulations that represent every insect, the study shows that these multiple matings do not affect the sterile insect technique in the same way in the short term and in the long term.

Question

When the females of a pest mate several times, can the way they use stored sperm change the outcome of sterile male releases?

Approach

A compartmental model (differential equations) and an individual-based model written in Python with the Mesa library, comparing several sperm-use rules: first male, last male, mixing, choice and preference.

Research area

Cite

Courtois, M. A., van Oudenhove, L., Touzeau, S., Grognard, F., & Mailleret, L. (2026). Polyandry: A threat or an opportunity for the sterile insect technique?. PLOS Computational Biology, 22(4), e1014212. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014212

Show the BibTeX entry
@article{courtois2026polyandry,
  title = {{Polyandry: A threat or an opportunity for the sterile insect technique?}},
  author = {Courtois, Marine A. and van Oudenhove, Louise and Touzeau, Suzanne and Grognard, Frédéric and Mailleret, Ludovic},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {22},
  number = {4},
  pages = {e1014212},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014212},
  url = {https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014212}
}

Discover

Can a female that mates several times defeat biological control?

In many insects, females mate with several males and store their sperm. A female mated with a sterile male can therefore still reproduce thanks to a wild male, and the reverse is also true.

Understand

It all depends on how the sperm is used.

After several matings, which sperm fertilises the eggs? The first received, the last, preferably the fertile, preferably the sterile, or a mix? These mechanisms are still poorly known.

A first model, called compartmental, follows average numbers (how many larvae, males, females): it measures the overall effect of multiple matings. A second, individual-based, follows each female and the sperm she has stored: it compares the ways that sperm can be used.

Sperm-use rule

200

Equivalent to 10,000 individuals per day at the scale of the original model.

Individual scale — females and the content of their spermatheca

Day 0: .

  • fertile
  • fertile + sterile
  • sterile
  • unmated

Population scale

day 0 / 100 · replicate no. 1

  • Larvae
  • Females
  • Wild males
Individual-based simulation, last rule, 200 sterile males per day. Day 0: 0 larvae, 0 females, 0 wild males, 0 sterile males.0200400600800020406080100time (days)individuals (1/50 scale)

Go deeper

Model, assumptions, results and limits.

A compartmental model based on differential equations measures the overall effect of multiple matings. An individual-based model, calibrated on Drosophila suzukii, compares several ways of using sperm: priority to the first or the last male, to fertile or sterile sperm, or a mix of both.

Assumptions

  • Females can mate several times and store the sperm of several males.
  • Several sperm-use rules are explored as scenarios, since no mechanism is established.
  • Biological parameters of the individual-based model calibrated on Drosophila suzukii.

Published results

  • In the long term, multiple matings are a drawback: more releases of sterilised males are needed to control the population.
  • In the short term, they can help by “defertilising” females already mated with wild males.
  • Depending on the release effort that can be deployed, the way sperm is used may have only a limited influence.

Limits

  • Sperm-use mechanisms remain poorly known: the scenarios cover several possibilities without deciding between them.
  • The individual-based model is calibrated on a single species.

Observethe mechanism

In Drosophila suzukii, females can mate several times. The model separates females fertilised by a fertile male (FF) or a sterile one (FI); remating moves them from one state to the other.

“First”: only the first mating counts (τ = 0). “Last”: the last mating determines the offspring (τF = 0.12; τI = 0.14 per day).

L˙=ω(1−LK)FF−(μL+ν)L\dot L = \omega\left(1-\tfrac{L}{K}\right)F_F - (\mu_L+\nu)LM˙=νpL−μMM,S˙=σ−μSS\dot M = \nu p L - \mu_M M,\qquad \dot S = \sigma - \mu_S SF˙F=ν(1−p) πML+τIπMFI−(μF+τFπS)FF\dot F_F = \nu(1-p)\,\pi_M L + \tau_I \pi_M F_I - (\mu_F + \tau_F \pi_S)F_FF˙I=ν(1−p) πSL+τFπSFF−(μF+τIπM)FI\dot F_I = \nu(1-p)\,\pi_S L + \tau_F \pi_S F_F - (\mu_F + \tau_I \pi_M)F_I

πM=MM+ηS, πS=ηSM+ηS\pi_M = \frac{M}{M+\eta S},\ \pi_S = \frac{\eta S}{M+\eta S}

Explorethe parameters

450 k/day

Initial infestation

  • No releases
  • “First” — first male
  • “Last” — last male
Larval density over 5000 days for σ = 450000 sterile males per day, high infestation. End of simulation: 0 larvae under the First rule, 22,693 under the Last rule.010k20k30k010002000300040005000time (days)larval density L

Understandthe results

At the end of the simulation: 0 larvae (“First”) and 22,693 (“Last”).

Compare the two horizons: depending on the release intensity, the rule that brings the population down fastest at first is not necessarily the one that eliminates it in the long term.

Courtois, van Oudenhove, Touzeau, Grognard & Mailleret (2026). PLOS Computational Biology 22(4): e1014212.

TypeScript port (RK4, step 0.05 day) of the notebook's modele_SIT system, with the notebook's parameters (μL = 0.037; K = 36,000; η = 0.6…). Checked: reproduces panels A and B of the First/Last figure for σ = 300,000, 450,000 and 600,000. Teaching exploration: it does not replace the published analyses.

Left, stochastic trajectories of the number of larvae over 100 days for several sperm-use rules; right, reduction of the area under the curve for each scenario.
Individual-based model: repeated larval dynamics and reduction of the area under the curve by sperm-use scenario.thesisData — Chapter 4 - Multiple Mating/ABM_model_output.ipynb
Two panels of larval density over time for three release intensities, comparing the “First” (blue) and “Last” (orange) sperm-use scenarios under high (A) and low (B) initial infestation.
Compartmental model: larval density by sperm-use rule (first or last male).thesisData — Chapter 4 - Multiple Mating/Compartmental_model_output_vAvril.ipynb
The project: individual-based model and app